As promised in my previous post about the 20-volume extension to the DC Heroes & Villains Collection – which, lest we forget (and I mean how could we when I'm forever banging on about it), I'm the editor of – I thought I'd delve a little deeper into the extension than the four volumes thus far announced – or rather five, as subscribers have also been told about the 400-page Batman: Under the Red Hood. That volume's not due to be published until next spring, but it's worth spending a moment on it now because it might help illuminate how both the extension and the collection as a whole developed.
Way back in the mists of time, or more accurately the tail end of 2019, when I first noted down some thoughts on which stories we could potentially include in the collection, Judd Winick, Doug Mahnke and co.'s Red Hood storyline from Batman was one of those on my initial list. It's a run of comics that I loved when it was first published in the mid-2000s, a twisty-turny Bat-thriller that audaciously brought back a character who had been killed off in the late-1980s, yet kept readers guessing as to the true identity of that character (much as Ed Brubaker and Steve Epting were doing around the same time with their Winter Soldier storyline in Captain America; truly the mid-2000s were a great time to be reading superhero comics).
With a licensed partwork like the DC Heroes & Villains Collection, there's often a bit of give and take in terms of what can and can't be included, and for whatever reason, possibly the storyline's length (I can't actually remember at this point), Under the Red Hood didn't make it onto the final list of 100 volumes. But in common with some other titles that fell by the wayside, I never forgot about it – you should see my various voluminous docs of notes and ideas – and promised myself that should the collection ever be extended I'd revisit it, even though its length would likely mean splitting it across two volumes.
Incidentally, on the subject of the extension, there's an assumption amongst those familiar with partwork graphic novel collections that they always get extended past their initial run, but I had every reason to believe that the DC Heroes & Villains Collection would end at 100 volumes. Its extension was a genuine surprise to me, albeit a pleasant one, because it represented an opportunity to revisit previously rejected volumes and include new ones.
As discussions about the extension between myself, Hachette and DC developed – over a very short space of time I should add, as confirmation of the extension came quite late in the day – it became clear that not only would we be able to revisit stories that had fallen by the wayside and add in stories only relatively recently published, but include stories that I didn't think we'd ever get agreement on – and furthermore have a number of volumes with greater page counts, including one 400-page one.
Well hello, Batman: Under the Red Hood.
Once Under the Red Hood came into play – and after a different story dropped out of the extension – I started thinking about another title I intended to include: a volume collecting the first half of Jim Starlin's late-1980s Batman run, including the classic Ten Nights of the Beast. If those comics were on the table alongside the Red Hood storyline, wouldn't it make sense to also include the second half of Starlin's run, in particular the notorious A Death in the Family...?
I shan't spoil the events of those stories for anyone who hasn't read then, but anyone familiar with them will understand the significance of Starlin and Winick's respective Batman runs appearing in sequence in the collection's extension. And the icing on the cake: I'd already determined to try and include Jim Starlin's other significant Bat-story, the 1988 Prestige Format miniseries Batman: The Cult – with art by the great Bernie Wrightson – and so the extension will feature all of the Bat-books written by Starlin, brought together in a unique fashion.
Batman: Ten Night of the Beast has already been announced as the fourth release in the extension, published at the start of 2025, while Batman: The Cult, Batman: A Death in the Family and Batman: Under the Red Hood will be arriving in February, March and April – and of course will be stuffed with extras and bonus content. Before those, however, there are two other volumes set for a January release:
The Man of Steel, which collects the start of Ultimate Spider-Man co-creator Brian Michael Bendis's Superman run from 2018 and features spectacular art by Jim Lee, José Luis García-López, Ivan Reis, Jason Fabok, Evan "Doc" Shaner, Steve Rude, Ryan Sook, Kevin Maguire and Adam Hughes;
and The Joker: Vengeance, which collects the entire 21-chapter lead story from James Tynion IV, Guillem March and co.'s 2021–2022 The Joker series: to my mind one of the most gripping comics storylines of the past five years, in one unique 300-plus-page volume.
As for the other titles to be released early next year, not to mention the remainder of the DC Heroes & Villains Collection extension... more anon.
